Local Business Comments

Local Business Comments

Recently, there was a disagreement in practice of how to properly utilize Google Maps for Local Business.   This disagreement stemmed from an unfortunate practice that is making the service less and less reliable.  For some time now, businesses in general have been leaving their own string of positive statements on the optional commenting spaces.  hidden linksThis is problematic in quite a few ways,and can lead to a negative response from those in web design, SEO, and the general public.

While looking through the site index of our business listing, I came across several negative remarks that were coming from a group of people who were also commenting positively about a similar business within the local area.  As a web designer, I always make it a point to not speak negatively of our competitors, and in most cases, I’ll not comments at all on their business unless they are the very best in the field.

After reading a few of the comments, it was apparent that they were coming from someone associated with the business and from the same individual.  This persons business had roughly 20 “positive” comments about their business, but had not made the effort to ensure that they weren’t noticeably written by the same individual.  Inevitably, another web designer began making fun of the scenario.

This is where the self serving positive comment become a nightmare for multiple businesses.  For reasons unknown, this business owner began raging against his competitors, Naper Design included.  Since we focus on both Web Design and SEO, he assumed that all of the joking statements must be coming from our team.  Admittedly, we did have a few clients who were less than kind with their responses to his form of deception, but he only took this to mean that we were involved.  His response was to post this laundry list of negative statements about our company to the point that he’d committed slander and defamation of character.

The situation was resolved with the assurance of our strong legal teams ability to sue him,  and the comments were removed within just a few minutes(proving they had been written all by him).  He still maintains a large list of fake comments on his page, and assuredly, others will likely continue to make light of the shady business practice.

I referred to it as “shady business practice”.

I did son because that’s exactly what it is.  When afforded the chance to have clients give feedback, both positive and negative, some businesses will immediately begin writing comment after comment about their own business to appear more user friendly.  While this is not one of the more hanus actions a business can commit,  it is one of deception and can be easily dtected by those reading the responses. If the comments are written in the same style and manner, if they are written in a way that shows the same character, and if they are in the same vernacular, it becomes obvious to the reader that they have been forged by one single individual.

While this situation has been resolved, multiple businesses have sustained damage to their credibility and are working hard to repair the damages made by these actions.  As a web designer, credibility is something that has to be earned, not self stamped within a comment field.  If found to be untrue or being decptive in ones actions, a web design company can lose all of its business and clients from just such an action.

I don’t wish for this competing business to go under and hope for their recuperation after these recent events, but I do hope that they learn to not make such blatant attempts at manipulating the system.  The web design community may be competitive, but that doesn’t prevent us from being both civil and cooperative.

Share this post

Comments (3)

  • Services Man

    Reminds me of a company I’ve seen a lot lately in Naperville. He post lot of positive comments about his business on Google, but it’s easily evident that he wrote them all. Insurance guys in Naperville shouldn’t be offering SEO or Web Design. We know you guys have done well, and will likely be having our new site built by you next month.

    January 5, 2010 at 6:18 am
  • BernieR

    So it’s wrong for me to add a few good comments to my portfolio….?
    I thought everyone did. At least having some friends do it…. Ya know

    March 30, 2010 at 3:12 pm
  • Dingo

    OK man. I agree. But there isn’t much you can do about guys like Flood Control (yeah, I looked them up and they are a total scam. I mean, they’re just going to add more and more fake positions until Google finally boots them from the map(and with how they’ve been lately, hope you’ve got a Snickers bar).
    And you realize, as soon as they do finally get banned, they’re just going to upload a lot of new, fake domains?
    They and the lead-bots are all the same. Kill them in one area, they come back at another.

    April 3, 2010 at 3:55 pm

Leave a Reply